Monday, January 23, 2006


Readers of this blog know that I don't care much for C.S. Lewis, that his fiction and nonfiction leave me cold. But there's an exception, and it's so grand I can almost forgive the man his crimes against literature: Perelandra, the second novel of his space trilogy. I will be analyzing this story in a series of posts over the next two weeks.

Perelandra serves an evangelical purpose like anything else Lewis wrote, but I think it can work for the secular reader as much the Christian, reading like mythology or science-fiction. It's a fascinating and intense examination of how a person from an unfallen world processes thought, and what she is capable of doing as she struggles to think for herself. Try and imagine a world where everything is good -- there aren't even words for "bad" or "evil" -- its (two) people so in touch with their deity that stepping outside his will is impossible to conceive, at least on their own.

The paradise is planet Venus, a world populated by floating islands surrounding a Fixed Land from which the man and woman are banned: they may visit the Fixed Land, but not sleep on it, nor dwell there for too long. The devil arrives on Venus in human form, his task to achieve exactly what he did millennia ago on Earth as a snake: persuade the woman to break the ban, and make the human race fall a second time.

But there's a difference between what's happening now on Perelandra (Venus) and what happened before on Eden (Earth). A human agent from Earth in the 1940s, Elwin Ransom, has been sent by an angel to combat the devil and prevent him from succeeding a second time. The stakes are even higher than before, for apparently the devil has a more difficult time wrecking God's creation with each successive attempt. Correspondingly, if he does succeed, God's redemptive measures become increasingly drastic and brutal. Late in the story, Ransom reflects:
"If he now failed, this world [like Earth] would hereafter be redeemed... [But] not a second crucifixion: perhaps -- who knows -- not even a second Incarnation... some act of even more appalling love, some glory of yet deeper humility. For he had seen already how the pattern grows and how from each world it sprouts into the next through some other dimension. The small external evil which Satan had done [on Mars] was only a line: the deeper evil he had done on Earth a square: if Venus fell, her evil would be a cube -- her Redemption beyond conceiving." (126)
The story of Mars is related in the trilogy's first book, Out of the Silent Planet, an adventure story that in some ways inverts the premise of H.G. Wells' classic. Satan's damage on Mars was minimal (there wasn't a fall requiring redemption), and for all practical purposes the planet never had much to worry about, unlike Earth and Venus. But if Venus' redemptive measures would require a "cube" over Earth's "square"... that's like asking us to contemplate the horror of Passion of the Christ times ten, or worse.

In the next post we will begin going through the story of Perelandra and see what happens when Ransom first encounters the Lady on Venus, before the devil arrives. It's a clash of psyches, handled brilliantly by Lewis, between the fallen and unfallen as they try to understand each other.


Blogger Andrew Criddle said...

I'm surprised you don't like Lewis' "Till We Have Faces" (his retelling of Cupid and Psyche) which I would have expected to appeal to you.

Blogger Loren Rosson III said...

I don't dislike that one with the same intensity I do the Narnian stories. I feel the same way about Out of the Silent Planet. They're okay, but not that great. Only in Perelandra do I see a real literary genius at work.

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Haven't you read Screwtape letters, etc.?

Blogger RU said...

CS Lewis is one of the most brilliant writers of the century. Perhaps you can't handle the messages of TRUTH that are in his novels? Narnia is a beautiful story of redemption, perhaps you should read it again.

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Perelandra is a beautiful and mentally stimulating novel. Perelandra will probably be made into a major motion picture.

Blogger Nathan said...

A major motion picture with obvious Christian references throughout and protagonists who are all completely naked the whole time? Yeah, there's a big market for that. I could see That Hideous Strength making a fine movie, in the hands of the right director. But this one just ain't a-gonna work.

Anonymous AutreVie said...

Loren, I liked Perelandra too. Have you read 'That Hideous Strength'? It follows Perelandra but is quite different from it. You might try reading 'The Place of the Lion' (1931) by Charles Williams before attempting 'That Hideous Strength' - you might get more out of it.


Post a Comment

<< Home